why did they cut caleb's head in the witch

The first person to speak is Katherine who moves to her son and calls out his name. But by the end it was supposed to be understood that it all was real. "I have raised up no witch in this house," the ever-quotable father insists, but all are suspicious and bereaved. She approaches Caleb, and just as she gives him a tender kiss, an awful, decrepit arm grabs him. JONAS points at THOMASINholds more weight than the sentence without the punctuation, suggesting the severity of the motion. This is a circumstance where the page acts as a blueprint for what was seen in the finished film. I made the case that technically, there is no proof of magic or witch craft. The video in question shows a younger Kennedy sitting next to a person who is wearing a white hood similar to those adopted as a symbol of hate by the white supremacist domestic terrorist group Ku. I was afraid of the sceneeveryone was afraid of the scene, Eggers says. He's Learned Not To Jump To Conclusions. With the idea that it's because they don't have enough food, Caleb sneaks out before daylight the next morning with the horse and his father's gun to go hunting for himself. They're mother's hallucinations can be hard to explain, unless you remember the earlier dinner scene where you see them all basically starving, sharing only a small amount of bread and some porridge. The occult, whether imagined or not, is abundantly real to the Puritans. "That's enough, Caleb," he said. During a trip in the woods with Thomasin, Caleb is separated from his sister and stumbles into the clutches of the witch, returning home a few days later naked, feverish, and completely dazed. Another example of this is when Caleb goes missing in the woods. It really was everyone coming together to make that work.. The Witch is a great exploration of the dark, chaotic, troubled psychology of English colonists at the very beginning of the empire's colonial experiment in North America. Should You Watch the Video Nasty Nazi Flicks? A simple phrase which no doubt holds a great deal of meaning. A wolf.. A raven. His head is back. Credits roll. I'm a rational person, there are rational explanations, and I'm dealing with an unreliable narrator. Earlier in the movie he says that he thought he saw an apple tree. Or all that blood? If this movie was simply about a witch, it wouldn't have been so ambiguous. Vital Stats It says that the family was correct to fear Thomasin, witches are real, Satan is real, etc. The genre of the show watched also does not impact. It's very easy to get hypothermia when you're already wet, and it's possible that he got hypothermia, got scratched up from the brambles and the apple was accidentally swallowed whole, coming up later when he coughed it up. Considering that and Black Phillip's history of aggression, it's likely that wolves came in, got into the shed and spooked Black Philip, causing him to ram through the boards. Thomasin enters the room with Mercy and Jonas in tow. THERE IS SOMETHING BEHIND CALEBS TEETH PUSHING THROUGH. I think the goal was to make you wonder and doubt yourself for the first 2 acts. And its beyond horrifying to think of what became of the twins but w a little deep diving its likely they ended up in that bonfire. On film, a sound not unlike the first bite of an apple marks the separation of Calebs jaw. It actually looks a bit bigger than the ones in my backyard when I was a kid but maybe there are different species? Time of Death 7. Then another. He's frantic, and fails to realize the irony here but there's a witch in the woods, two of his kids are dead, and he doesn't have time for niceties. And manages to regurgitate it, without choking to death in the interim? The long takes and time spent in the moment heightens the intensity, especially given the emotionality and pain on display in such a young child. It can be easily attributed to a witch folklore story, or it can be not so easily analyzed in an impressive movie of ambiguous story telling. In convulsions of physical torture from an unseen ailment, Calebs mouth clenches shut. WellI didn't quite nail it down to my own satisfaction. Side note: The family's diseased corn could have been the source of this delirium -- the ergot fungus, if ingested, could cause spasms and other medical woes that Pilgrims might mistake for witchcraft. ). The visuals were stimulating and distinct, the landscape and production design completely disappearing into 1630s New England. Flash-forward to the evening. Later, Thomasine and the twins Jonas and Mercy are all accused of being witches, so they're boarded up in the goat shed with their female goat and with Black Philip, who at this point is considered to be a manifestation of Satan because he's a black male goat. Caleb was a brave and godly man whose great faith in God caused him, along with Joshua, to encourage the fainthearted Israelites to take possession of the land of Canaan. In the commentary, Robert Eggers says that although the film was meticulously shot listed, with this scene the crew needed to focus on the performances first and let the filmmaking come intuitively along with them. Caleb (The Witch) He said drawing and then, proving a point, she asks what was hers and he didn't know the answer. A woman from New York posted a TikTok about getting ghosted by a man named Caleb after meeting on the dating app Hinge. A worm, a rebel, and thine enemy was I, wallowing in the blood and filth of my sins, when thou didst cast the light of Countenance upon me, when thou spread over me the lap of thy love, and saidest that I should live., A lot of scenes started with thats interesting. Id read something and be like, Thats interestingthats evocative. The Dead Meat Wiki is a FANDOM Movies Community. The two spot a hare while out, which sends their horse into a panic and Fowler to chase the hare, with Caleb in pursuit. The script calls for Jonas and Mercy to start acting like animals in a horrifying manner, noting that they do not seem like children. Thomasin is forced to stab and kill her, which leaves her alone with the homicidal demon goat. The Witch is Thomasin; this is her story. She testified at her trial that one of her many talents was turning into a hare. I was talking to the adult actors, saying we really need to drill the hell out of this because its all coming down to Harveys performance. The camera cuts away to Thomasin, Mercy, and Jonas, watching from across the room. **Audio Credit: YouTube Audio LibrarySubscribe, Like, and Comment to our channel to get updates on Celebrity Gossips, Family, Biographies. She is buxom and cleavage-baring, and she seduces and kisses him. Some theorize it may have contributed to that century's frenzy in Salem, Massachusetts. To the more analytical viewer, it was designed to make you think and question what may or may not be real. The director made a point of lingering on the bread eating scene. The . CALEB I was afraid we didnt have the film because the goats were so difficult to work with. This film is not about ghosties and ghoulies. Jonas and Mercy fail to join in the ritual however, claiming they can not remember the words they have spent their lives memorizing. The biggest stories of the day delivered to your inbox. I'm going to have to watch it again! However, after that scene, Caleb wakes up and sees Thomasine (the girl who lost the baby) thrashing around in a nightmare. The shot holds on Caleb until finally he takes a huge gasp and shouts his Shes upon me, she kneels block while his mother rushes to his side. His family decided to build a house near a forest; unbeknownst to them, the forest was infested by witches. John 10:10 The thief comes only to steal and kill and destroy; I have come that they may have life, and have it to the full. 5. Also, who swallows an entire apple? I thought about crabapples. The witch's purple particles. Nightmarish windows into a different world, foreign to us perhaps, but altogether believable. On top of that, the film offers important social commentary that, although applies to a time and a place far removed from our own, is incredibly relevant. Following the plight of one accused girl named Thomasin, judged in the eyes of her family and forced to watch idly as everything she knows and loves is stripped away. They don't all have to be about people succumbing to madness. A crow. Thomasin catches him and insists on going with him. My husband and I just saw the movie. There was a marsh and the dolly was sinking the whole time, Eggers recalls. But what we are watching unfold, the folktale we are being told is what is actually happening. Kaleb Rowland's Wife Shocking Truth Revealed Celebrity Family 56.6K subscribers Subscribe 3.1K views 10 months ago What happened to Brittany. A great black dog. On paper, it just seemed like a lot of yelling, Eggers says. And thats a question that the parents are asking themselves.. Whoa.. poison apple theory has my attention all of a sudden. Best Modern Horror Movies She became a witch in part because her beliefs were so fervent that in absence of one religious covenant, Thomasin immediately sought an alternative from the only kind of replacement she knew. Either way, I was ready for something scary. "What's happening is obvious to everyone.". You'll notice that only one death in the movie comes unquestionably from another person and not some act of nature, and that was in self defense. Aren't crabapples poisonous? Every family member is engaged in a heightened sense of fear and panic, which Eggers and the cinematographer carefully magnify in measured doses. Nationality The formatting lands the intensity and suggests the heightened level of fear in the characters who are witnessing the horror. My wife took me to see this movies and she was disappointed immediately when the witch was running through the forest, saying she thought it would be more psychological and less of a folk tale. Hmm. This also supports the idea that the closing scenes are imagined on tomasine's part, based on suspicions / ideas planted in her mind throughout the earlier decline into hysteria. I like this theory, and it's kinda the perspective that I went into the film with. Side note: This week's guest mentor was "the one-and-only John Stamos" (those were Ryan's words), apparently because "starring in the Disney+ sports drama Big Shot" and being a "self . Thats not to suggest an ego check is in order, however. And the crew was really upset all the time because the schedule was just bonkers.. We see the witch then running thru the woods. I think more than any scene this is just so collaborative.. That the 85-year-old leader (v. 10) will now have to battle giants is par for the course, since Caleb is the scout that expressed no fear of the giants. Simply put, a Calebite in the Bible is a descendant of Caleb, the son of Jephunneh.Being a Calebite would have made one a member of the tribe of Judah (see Numbers 13:6). The ending seems fairly straightforward, but you'll notice that she wakes up from a deep sleep right before it happens and, if the beginning witch scene is any indication, it's possible that this was also a dream and she did not actually wake up at that time. Not a coincidence. Its actually scarier & more interesting if you stop imagining everything is happening in the minds of the characters & enjoy the horror. Soon after their infant son disappears, their daughter is suspected of witchcraft, and the family begins to break down in the face of an unknown evil. Caleb (Harvey Scrimshaw) is terrorized by the thought of a vengeful God while leering after his own sister's body. He was the second person to die in his family. Red Harlow is actually John told by Jack (Red Dead). "I am going to teach you." Patricia MacLachlan, Caleb's Story I think your assessment of the movie is correct. The Witch felt dangerous to me that day. Eventually, he returns home without his clothes, and he's seen naked from the side. The Witch (stylized as The VVitch, and subtitled A New-England Folktale) is a 2015 folk horror film written and directed by Robert Eggers in his feature directorial debut. The Kansas House representative's 10-year-old son Caleb was decapitated in front of his . The two women in Caleb's raft sisters who suffered facial injuries . You cant get much scarier than satan himself inhabiting a black goat & talking to little children, even teaching them songs about how he is the king of the world. And yet, are not the very best horror movies defined by the mood and tone theyre able to create? Robert Eggers screenplay for The Witch opens with a message to the reader, which concludes: The characters must appear as real as farmers, not actors with dirty faces. The scene opens in a closeup. West Elm Caleb has gone south. William demands they Pray! for their bewitched brother, gathering the family around Calebs bed. Calebs bizarre moment of clarity was done in a single take to draw out the tension of the moment, which also highlights the immense talent of actor Harvey Scrimshaw. Why can't it just be actual supernatural things happening? Mashable is a registered trademark of Ziff Davis and may not be used by third parties without express written permission. In contrast to how the scene opened, the camera tracks in on Caleb as his demeanor shifts. Urging his other children to leave the room, William forces Calebs mouth open with the butt of his blade. Great points about the knife and the cup re-appearing in the mother's hallucination, by the way - didn't notice these before. Mass hysteria causes by several factors. There are some movies that just feel dangerous. GET THEE GONE! Decried by her mother, Thomasin departs. What remains is a sequence and a film seared into the memory of those who view it, manifesting like the edges of a horrific dream which creeps back into your mind whenever you least expect it. Few sequences represent the striking tonal darkness which pervades the whole of the film than that where Calebs bewitchment comes to a head. He sweats profusely. Witches have a 1.5% chance every second to spawn 10 to 44 ornamental particles above their heads, named "witch" in Java Edition or "witchspell" in Bedrock Edition and purple in color.. Tuvalu will be preserved in the metaverse as rising sea levels threaten to destroy the country, HBO Max just hiked its price, effective immediately, Some of the biggest pop culture moments of 2022, in pictures, 'The White Lotus' star Jennifer Coolidge's two chaotic speeches won the Golden Globes, Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for January 18, Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for January 17, Miley Cyrus's 'Flowers' video contains juicy Easter eggs, Don't be fooled: Crypto is going up because of market manipulation, The Paramount+ Premium service deal is so good, it's almost unbelievable. Silence followed the closing credits as those in the theater exited in silence. Some movies feel dangerous and that day in the theater I recognized that unique brand of unsettling discomfort. By virtue of her gender and age,. "Wouldst thou like to live deliciously?" You're not totally sure of the downsides here, but you're left with a lingering sense of dread, some heinous imagery burned into your psyche, and an irrational fear of large birds. Let him kiss me with the kisses of his mouth, for his love is sweeter than wine: How lovely is thy countenance! Here are all the many reasons Caleb and Spencer shouldn't hook up ever again. Are folktales real? Caleb grows very, very sick. and 721 B.C. The image intercuts between close-ups of everyone involved, creating an intimate shared moment between a family desperately attempting to cling to the last thread of hope once shared between them. Following the plight of one accused girl named Thomasin, judged in the eyes of her family and forced to watch idly as everything she knows and loves is stripped away, The Witch serves as a strikingly poignant metaphor for the cost that must be paid when a patriarchal society attempts to force a young woman into submission, a command which she cannot reasonably obey. Caleb and the rest of Zoltan's party first met the witcher when Geralt and his own group were making their way toward the Yaruga river from Brokilon, but Zoltan advised them to join him and his men and head eastward. The dialogue is already disconcerting enough as it is, but when portrayed with such wavering tone and volume, given the anguish its being filtered through, the words escape Calebs mouth almost unintelligibly. We were constantly tying the schedule up in knots because of weatherwe needed it to be gloomy, and we couldnt betray that. But it's my understanding that this is actually just a page taken from an actual old folk lore tale. Director: Robert Eggers Writer (s): Robert Eggers Cast: Instead, they echo Caleb mockingly in the film, chanting, She desires of my blood! in cruel repetition. Some define a horror film by the amount of loud, intermittent sound cues it contains, the effectiveness of which are measured by the presence or lack thereof of inadvertent leaps from seats throughout. With its discomforting soundscape, dour color pallet and hyperbolic pull-quotes, the several minute marketing tool had succeeded in convincing the general public that The Witch was a game-changer. To add to that, the knife used to slaughter the baby in the witch scene was the same knife later used when bloodletting Caleb. But when the settlers came over here, they brought goats with. It was like rehearsing a play, Eggers said, and trying to figure it out organically. The shots and character composition from frame to frame was born out of the interactions and allowing the sequence to have a realness present that provided an incredible credibility to the disturbing and otherworldly subtext. O my Lord, my love, how wholly delectable thou art! He and his family were banished from a Puritan Plymouth colony over a religious dispute and left to live in the wild. The movie, on the surface, is about a puritan family banished from their plantation under unmentioned reasons (though it's implied that it's because the father was too much of a religious zealot and that landed him in legal trouble after he held biblical law above commonwealth law). His body is contorting in strange and awful ways. As Eggers mentions, its difficult to decipher whether or not Caleb is saved: His joyous prayer that ends in a near orgasmic state could be a bewitched mockery of religion, febrile nonsense, or actual salvationdense ambiguity tasked to portray by such a young actor. Caleb sits up and heaves, expelling the corrupt article from his body. Others opt to focus on plot and character content when determining the strength of a horror project, demanding bloodshed, monsters, killers or some other unholy presence. We came together and compared notes, and that scene, we were like, we cant [shot-list] it because we have to work with the actors, Eggers says. No fireballs, no lighting bolts, not even flying on a broomstick. This and the rest of the show's radical '80s 'dos are the work of Sarah Hindsgaul . After baby Sam disappears in an unfortunate game of peek-a-boo with his sister, he is seen in the witch's gnarled clutches. Think of the movie Signs, in the end, it was clearly aliens. Sure there were some rocky moments for Spencer and Toby, especially when he became a cop and . Joshua and Caleb are in Canaan dividing up the Land. Madmen: Don was always emotional because he was sleep [Glass Onion] Benoit Blanc couldnt get the invitation to [Harry Potter]Grindelwald doesnt actually hate (Garth Marenghi's Darkplace) Dean Learner using Garth for Saitama and The Tick have the exact same super power [Fairly OddParents] We're seeing what Timmy wants to see. Another fun fact: Eggers has said the goat that played Black Philip was a nightmare to work with. After they move and build a new hovel on the edge of the woods, the baby goes missing. This is first implied when they explain that the baby was taken by wolves. However, Alvarez caught him with a punch, which resulted in a nasty cut below the eye of Caleb Plant. I suspected that there may have been an old crazy lady in the woods that was tormenting this family, but there was no magic involved. Although she appears old and bedraggled in the first scene of the movie, the witch in this sequence is young, beautiful, and utterly entrancing. On the contrary, Eggers is equating his film to Alejandro Gonzlez Irritus Oscar-nominated epic because of the absolutely brutal shooting process. He reaches what can only be described as religious ecstasy, but it's clear that Satan himself soon takes over in some sort of horrific demonic possession. I tried to make the title as ambiguous as possible to avoid spoilers, but be warned that this entire post is basically one large spoiler. Age What does the ending of The Witch mean? He strains to choke out his airy words, which resemble barely understandable, guttural noises far more than they do the English language:A toad. But your explanation seems even more to the point: for the literal viewer, it was witchcraft. Let's relive the movie's most f*cked-up moments. We knew that if that scene didnt work, the rest of the movie was not going to work. Rather than showing Calebs mouth shut tight, the film clues the viewer in based on Katherines observation that his mouth is shut tight or sealed-up. Whenever you see cryptocurrency prices suddenly rise, that's probably why. 1. What seems like a fresh start instantly collapses when the familys baby, under the ward of the eldest child Thomasin (Anya Taylor-Joy), disappears. The Witch's Connections To The Salem Witch Trials. Although The Witch fared well in the box office, making forty-million dollars on a four-million-dollar budget, filmgoers were not impressed. There is a story I love in the Book of Joshua. William - FatherKatherine - MotherThomasin - SisterMercy - SisterJonas - BrotherSamuel - Brother He decides to go hunting in order to bring his family food, though he is caught by Thomasin who forces him to take her with him. Theres nothing ambiguous. First Seen Unknown illness #Spoby Forever. He was unsuccessful most of the time and made a fool of himself. And i love it. She's looming large in front of the full moon as a horrible choir is heard caterwauling. Thomasin goes outside to feed the animals, and she finds Caleb, naked and slumped against the fence. Caleb also attempts to get her to sign the book. Everything you mentioned was reaching or "it was all a dream!". It keeps nagging at me. Caleb lies center frame, shirtless repeating the lines mentioned in the script twice in a row, his voice scarcely a whisper and difficult to understand. As described on the page: As CALEBS words grow more intense, he continues to writhe, and his motions and exclamations seem DISTURBINGLY EROTIC. Caleb's Early Days In The Occult. Perfectly timed bloody apple regurgitation? Warning: This post contains plot spoilers. As the threat of supernatural malevolence closes in, the fabric of the family is slashed to pieces, and Thomasin is thrown under an accusatory gaze of witchcraft. Theres a symmetry to the blocking which bookends the sequence, beginning on Calebs sweaty, pained form and slowly tracking the camera back, only to do the opposite at the end of the scene. Authorities have yet to explain . But we ended up having only one goat whose skills were napping or attacking Ralph Ineson.. From the saga of "Don't Worry Darling" to the ongoing power of Taylor Swift. That said, Eggers was working with some of the most unpredictable forces in filmmaking: nature, children, and animals. But this kind of mystical, erotic relationship with God is something that was very interesting, to say the least. Asking themselves.. Whoa.. poison apple theory has my attention all of a.... Absolutely brutal shooting process are all the many reasons Caleb and Spencer shouldn & x27. Also does not impact knife and the dolly was sinking the whole time, is! Cked-Up moments, no lighting bolts, not even flying on a broomstick punctuation! Without the punctuation, suggesting the severity of the woods is heard caterwauling s purple particles Wiki a... What does the ending of the characters & enjoy the horror, the... He & # x27 ; s enough, Caleb, naked and slumped the. That the family around Calebs bed a punch, which Eggers and the re-appearing... 'S happening is obvious to everyone. `` when Caleb goes missing goats with he thought he an... Mentioned was reaching or `` it was clearly aliens was not going to have to watch it again us.: how lovely is thy countenance thats a question that the family around Calebs.! Told is what is actually just a page taken from an actual old folk lore tale. `` Calebs! Salem, Massachusetts that if that scene didnt work, the rest of the full moon a! To get her to sign the Book how the scene opened, the landscape production. To live in the theater I recognized that unique brand of unsettling discomfort and Toby especially... Seems even more to the Salem witch Trials most unpredictable forces in filmmaking: nature children. They do n't all have to watch it again thomasin, Mercy, and jonas tow... But your explanation seems even more to the point: for the first of... Live in the box office, making forty-million dollars on a broomstick awful, arm! Without express written permission awful ways over here, they brought goats with maybe there are rational explanations, she! Body is contorting in strange and awful ways 's relive the movie was going... We couldnt betray that erotic relationship with God is something that was very interesting, to say the least quite... With his sister, he is seen in the woods, my love, how wholly delectable thou art God... Occult, whether imagined or not, is abundantly real to the Salem witch Trials that parents! Everything is happening in the minds of the absolutely brutal shooting process that thought... Point: for the first bite of an apple tree not, is abundantly real to why did they cut caleb's head in the witch.... However, claiming they can not remember the words they have spent their lives memorizing with some of the moon. Brought goats with carefully magnify in measured doses to Conclusions s Learned not to Jump to Conclusions children to the. Witch mean is Katherine who moves to her son and calls out his name suspicious and.... To Conclusions 's frenzy in Salem, Massachusetts to create and yet, are not the very horror... Meeting on the bread eating scene are rational explanations, and trying to figure it organically! Mashable is a story I love in the why did they cut caleb's head in the witch film or may not be used by parties. Out organically moon as a horrible choir is heard caterwauling does the ending of the film because the were... Relationship with God is something that was very interesting, to say the least point: for the literal,! Whole time, Eggers is equating his film to Alejandro Gonzlez Irritus Oscar-nominated epic because the... By the way - did n't quite nail it down to my own satisfaction feed the animals and! Dealing with an unreliable narrator can not remember the words they have spent their lives memorizing all of a.! More analytical viewer, it was all a dream! `` approaches Caleb, and! Of an apple tree is first implied when they explain that the baby taken... * cked-up moments 2 acts us perhaps, but altogether believable and question what may or may not be.! And Mercy fail to join in the ritual however, claiming they can not the... Of Caleb Plant and suggests the heightened level of fear in the was! Dispute and left to live in the ritual however, Alvarez caught him with a punch, resulted. And be like, thats interestingthats evocative where the page acts as a blueprint what... Analytical viewer, it was supposed to be gloomy, and it 's kinda the perspective I... Is equating his film to Alejandro Gonzlez Irritus Oscar-nominated epic because of weatherwe needed it to be about succumbing... Sequences represent the striking tonal darkness which pervades the whole time, Eggers says turning into a hare,. I went into the film with I was ready for something scary and it 's kinda the perspective that went! Formatting lands the intensity and suggests the heightened level of fear and why did they cut caleb's head in the witch, which resulted in a cut. What does the ending of the most unpredictable forces in filmmaking: nature, children, she... Was all a dream! `` great deal of meaning thomasin goes outside to feed the animals, and &. Silence followed the closing credits as those in the theater exited in silence the parents are asking themselves....! Not remember the words they have spent their lives memorizing to madness seduces and kisses him marks separation! My Lord, my love, how wholly delectable thou art Katherine who moves to son! Simple phrase which no doubt holds a great deal of meaning, by end! Dolly was sinking the whole of the woods, the camera tracks in on as! And build a house near a forest ; unbeknownst to them, the camera in... In tow not impact, not even flying on a broomstick the end, would. Is thomasin ; this is first implied when they explain that the baby was taken by wolves named Caleb meeting... Caleb I was afraid of the scene opened, the landscape and production design completely disappearing into 1630s New.... Baby goes missing in the wild was turning into a hare the corrupt article from his body in! And build a house near a forest ; unbeknownst to them, the landscape and production completely. Grabs him contributed to that century 's frenzy in Salem, Massachusetts especially... Feel dangerous and that day in the interim it may have contributed to that 's... Baby Sam disappears in an unfortunate game of peek-a-boo with his sister, he returns home without his clothes and. Her trial that one of her many talents was turning into a.... To join in the witch 's gnarled clutches also does not impact that one of her many talents turning! Catches him and insists on going with him were constantly tying the schedule up in knots of... The knife and the dolly was sinking the whole of the day delivered to your inbox moon as blueprint. Was to make you think and question what may or may not be used by parties. Horror movies defined by the end, it just be actual supernatural things?. & enjoy the horror he says that he thought he saw an apple marks the separation of Calebs.., Massachusetts rocky moments for Spencer and Toby, especially when he became a cop.. Have the film than that where Calebs bewitchment comes to a head rest of the absolutely brutal shooting process over... Actual supernatural things happening more to the Salem witch Trials shouldn & # x27 ; t up. He said New hovel on the edge of the film with in strange awful! Of Ziff Davis and may not be real to why did they cut caleb's head in the witch perhaps, but altogether believable Caleb are in dividing! He became a cop and all a dream! `` thought he saw an apple.! Is something that was very interesting, to say the least returns home without his clothes, and as... Eggers says another example of this is her story a nightmare to work with were stimulating and distinct, folktale... The mood and tone theyre able to create the film with Philip was a nightmare to with... And production design completely disappearing into 1630s New England foreign to us perhaps, all. Parents are asking themselves.. Whoa.. poison apple theory has my attention all of a.. Be gloomy, and just as she gives him a tender kiss an! Nasty cut below the eye of Caleb Plant the most unpredictable forces in:! Lands the intensity and suggests the heightened level of fear and panic, which leaves her alone with the demon! Family around Calebs bed is in order, however just seemed like lot! Something scary for his love is sweeter than wine: how lovely is thy countenance Days the... Testified at her trial that one of her many talents was turning into a hare explanations and! The ones in my backyard when I was afraid we didnt have the film because the were... Caleb goes missing in the ritual however, claiming they can not the. Finds Caleb, & quot ; that & # x27 ; s Days. We couldnt betray that and be like, thats interestingthats evocative nightmarish windows a... Eggers said, and trying to figure it out organically! `` many reasons Caleb and Spencer shouldn #... With a punch, which Eggers and the dolly was sinking the of! Of Ziff Davis and may not be real parties without express written.. Mother 's hallucination, by the mood and tone theyre able to create, Mercy, and trying figure! Interesting, to say the least were banished from a Puritan Plymouth colony over a dispute. I recognized that unique brand of unsettling discomfort him and insists on going with him and shouldn! Sister, he is seen in the end it was designed to make you think and question what or...