nuclear new york freak out

New York put out a PSA in case of a nuclear attack, leaving many The reactors' problem is that the price of electricity they sell on the high-voltage grid is depressed, mostly because of a surplus of natural gas. And if 25% more renewables can be built for half the cost of the nuclear subsidies, then the state could reduce emissions even more by implementing lower cost renewable energy. We are an extremely diverse group of individuals with different political affiliations, economic theories, cultural backgrounds, and walks of life. You're not going to see, really, ANY nuclear exchange but if you did, it would be small, tactical nukes targeting industry and military targets. Ginna Nuclear Power Plant, LLC. Nuclear New York is a project of Community Studies of New York, Inc, a 501(c)3 non-profit organization. Governor Cuomo and the PSC had to ignore all of these facts in order to justify subsidizing the nuclear industry. Observers believe Governor Cuomos real motivation for the nuclear subsidies is to avoid being held accountable for job losses in rural upstate counties, where he performed poorly in 2014. The commission only considered different methods subsidizing reactors to prevent them from closing next year. Many welcomed the closure. WAKE UP world!!! By Austin Michael Jul 14, 2022 | 8:04 PM If public service announcements started popping up on TV about what to do in a nuclear attack, I would start getting worried. Reuters NEW YORK, July 13 (Reuters) - New York City's emergency management office on Wednesday defended its decision to produce a public service announcement advising residents how to. Admin. If we want to reduce emissions, we must keep our nuclear plantswhich provide more than 50 percent of carbon-free electricity in the U.S.open. Since 1986, the radioactive site has remained frozen in time, and off limits to the public, after a reactor at the plant exploded. The panic is unnecessary, said Charles Forsberg, executive director of the MIT Nuclear Fuel Cycle Study. Time Out New York | New York Events and Things To Do All Year Nine Mile Point 1 and Ginna are two of the oldest reactors in the world, and their 60-year licenses expire in 2029. The plant was built to withstand an airplane crash in the 70s, New Yorks governor, Andrew Cuomo, said recently. Nuclear generates well-paid meaningful work that underwrites vibrant, healthy and prosperous communities. The video advises citizens to stay indoors and wash off any radioactive dust or ash. But to those close paying attention, it proves just the opposite: bailing out aging, uneconomical reactors is a massive diversion of time and money needed to invest in renewable energy, energy efficiency, and other strategies for reducing emissions. Equally prominent nuclear expert Jeffrey Lewis posted his own lengthy Twitter take, which was decidedly more critical of New York's nuclear PSA, contending its advice is "not much more than 'thoughts and prayers.' A lot of civil defense advice is like thatit's designed to make people feel better without really leveling with them." Dry casks, which contain spent fuel assemblies, are stored at Indian Point Energy Center. Energy & Financial Markets: What Drives Crude Oil Prices? That is 25% more renewable energy than nuclear, at half the cost of the nuclear subsidies. Entergys plan to run FitzPatrick until January was made to burn up more of the unused fuel in the reactor before the final shutdown. ), spending twice as much money propping up old nuclear power plants, reversing the states longstanding policy of closing those reactors, A study commissioned by environmental groups, Entergys plan to run FitzPatrick until January, http://www.eia.gov/dnav/ng/hist/n9011us2a.htm, http://www.peakchoice.org/peak-frack.html. (Noel Sickles art from "The 36-Hour War," Life, November 19, 1945, 35.) Contaminated milk posed the biggest peril. An employee at a Santa Monica Whole Foods said the store has been getting phone calls off the hook for the last week basically asking if we have it, while another staffer in Venice said his store was sold out but offered to put a caller on a list, though its 12 pages long., A spokeswoman for Whole Foods, Libba Letton, said hard numbers were not yet available but added, I can confirm that we had many customers asking about potassium iodide tablets, and some stores did sell out., The idea that dangerous levels of radiation could reach the U.S. is just incredible, Forsberg said. EIA's free and open data available as API, Excel add-in, bulk files, and widgets. Reactor operators Eugene Vanderbeek, left, and Andrew Goerres monitor Unit 3 from a control room at Indian Point Energy Center. This closure is about fear, unrealistic fear, of a nuclear accident. Tim is the Executive Director of Nuclear Information and Resource Service. Nuclear energy is something that were foisted on us in the 50s when I was still a small child. There may even be reason not to take potassium iodide. The nuclear age in the New York City area will end Friday night with the push of a button. Despite a full-court press by Exelon and the labor unions to drum up public support for nuclear, more than 80% of the public who spoke out at public hearings and filed comments in the case are against the nuclear subsidies, as are local elected officials, state legislators, and big businesses. See, as it turns out, nuclear explosions are not all that dramatic, especially if they're "only" releasing the equivalent a few tens of kilotons of TNT (i.e., a few times larger than the bombs dropped on Japan).. A behavioral research scientist says that rats are as trainable as dogs, but their small size makes them ideal for finding trapped people. The point I tried to make in the blog is that there is no reason for anyone else to follow New York off the edge of the cliff. But experts tell The Daily Beast it's "inconceivable" that dangerous radiation will reach the West Coast from Japan. A nuclear attack has not hit New York, but . Dave Sanders for The New York Times. The German Left's New Nuclear Freak-Out - The American Interest Nuclear New York - Reliable Carbon-Free Energy Climate Week NYC Seminar: Role of Nuclear in a Carbon-Free Future 19 September 2022 12:00pm-1:00pm EST featuring Isuru Seneviratne & Eric Dawson Video link to watch our virtual event will be posted here. 389,101 people die, including some who were killed by the National Guard or in the crush of people trying to escape the city. Shoppers at the GNC in Culver City will not be able to pick up Kelt pure iodide pills, which have sold out, but a cashier said the store does have plenty of multivitamins in stock, which contain the recommended dosage, 150 micrograms of potassium iodide. Nuclear New York is a project of Community Studies of New York, Inc, a 501 (c)3 non-profit organization. Get into a building and move away from windows. graphic showing decline of conventional nat. At the same time, wind and sun over the Hudson River alongside the plant pointed to the states energy future. Tools to customize searches, view specific data sets, study detailed documentation, and access time-series data. I got a look inside the control room at the Indian Point power plant . Dropping it on New York would be even more devastating, with an estimated . Challenge to N.Y. Nuclear Subsidies Will Go to Trial The current owner, Entergy, decided last year that it will close FitzPatrick in January 2017 and has been making the necessary preparations: notifying all of the relevant agencies, withdrawing applications for license amendments needed to continue operating, and canceling plans to refuel in September (next month). In Illinois, Exelon requires legislation to be enacted authorizing a nuclear subsidy program, and has been unable to convince legislators that the billion-dollar cost of the program is justified, even though it would be far less expensive than the subsidies proposed in New York ($300 million/year for eleven reactors, compared to $480 million/year for four reactors). Connecticut, Illinois, New Jersey and New York have offered financial support to struggling nuclear facilities in the name of preserving jobs and taming emissions. BREAKING: Trump Hits NUCLEAR Button - Democrats FREAK OUT If the electricity generated by nuclear power really is needed to keep emissions down, then almost all of it will need to be replaced by 2030, anyway. According to Nuclear New York, a group opposing closure, Indian Point produced 81% of downstate clean energy, with solar and hydro making up 2% and 4%. By 1985, the submarine K-431 was already twenty years old but still technically useful.Like all Echo IIs, K-431 was powered by two . New York State Assembly member Yuh-Line Niou and Rep. Mondaire Jones, candidates for the Democratic nomination in New York's 10th Congressional District, stand together during a Monday news conference to speak out against Dan Goldman's candidacy. ( NewsNation) New York City residents were rattled this week when the city's emergency management agency released a new 90-second public service announcement on surviving a nuclear attack. Horrifying photos of Chernobyl and its aftermath - CBS News The policy will lock in nuclear subsidies for 12 years (into 2029), for four reactors in one region of the stateGinna, FitzPatrick, and Nine Mile Point 1 and 2by declaring them a public necessity.. It is located on a 900-acre site that is shared by the FitzPatrick nuclear plant. New York has one of the lowest crime rates in the United States, and has a ridiculously low crime rate for such a densely populated diverse city. U.S. More than 91 million people would be killed or injured in the initial phase of a nuclear war between the U.S. and Russia, according to a simulation video released by Princeton University's. Even beyond the DRZ, sheltering may be warranted to minimize acute radiation exposure to the population and minimize cancer risk. Reactor Descriptions: FitzPatrick has a single, General Electric Type 4, boiling water reactor. Too cheap to meter, was the quote of the day. Energy-Related Carbon Dioxide Emissions, Energy-Related Carbon Dioxide Emissions at the State Level, through 2018, Eastern Mediterranean Regional Analysis Brief, Annual Solar Photovoltaic Module Shipments Report, Midwest and Rocky Mountain Transportation Fuels Markets, East Coast and Gulf Coast Transportation Fuels Markets. The Federal Emergency Management Agency's " Planning Guidance for Response to a Nuclear Detonation " offers more specifics. Greenhouse gas data, voluntary reporting, electric power plant emissions. Exelon had successfully lobbied the state to approve the Clean Energy Standard in August 2016, a program that requires all six New York investor-owned utilities and other energy suppliers to pay . Nuclear Winter (Short 2006) - IMDb The subsidies are intended to keep the four upstate reactors operating, since Ginna and FitzPatrick are now too expensive to operate without a lot of subsidies. The plant has provided about 1,000 well-paid jobs and half the towns tax revenue. Location and Service Territory: The Ginna nuclear plant is located on Lake Ontario, east of Rochester, New York. Your email address will not be published. FitzPatrick is already slated to close in January 2017, a decision the nuclear subsidies are intended to reverse (more below). In part, the plant was doomed by the attacks on the World Trade Center on 11 September 2001 the pilots of the hijacked planes used the river for navigation, alerting politicians to the vulnerability of the reactors on the banks of the Hudson. NIRS was extremely involved in the New York process, not just in this case but going back two years ago to fighting against subsidies for the Ginna reactor. Your donations make our work for a nuclear-free, carbon-free future possible. CVS, meanwhile, carries no radiation-fighting iodide, according to a representative. Eight years later, in 1965, Brookhaven updated its analysis of a worst-case scenario. My biggest concern is that sufficient resources are set aside because its not a revenue-generating business, he said. | GreenWorld. New York Times journalist Maggie Haberman reported the news in a Twitter post: Trump is still going. Cooling System: Cooling water is drawn from Lake Ontario through a submerged offshore intake at a rate of approximately 354,600 gallons per minute. The massive subsidies approved by New York yesterday are large enough to do that, and the price for Exelon appears to be taking on the risk of owning and operating FitzPatrick. The idea of dangerous levels of radiation from Japan reaching the U.S. is inconceivable, he said. The plant's two working reactors which account for roughly 10 percent of the state's power generation are slated to go offline in . New York airs PSAs about surviving nuclear attack, freak people out. This Is the End of Nuclear Energy in New York Its cheaper today to build out renewable generation than it is to continue to operate 40-year-old nuclear power plants.. But the shops usually do not carry potassium iodide in large quantities, and many have sold out and now have long waiting lists. There are many hurdles to get that done, Shillitto said. VIDEO: This is how a nuclear war would play out - New York Daily News In most other states, nuclear subsidy proposals have been proposed legislatively or through adjudicated processes where there has been a full, transparent review. Based on my review of publicly available documents and my interviews of witnesses, including employees of [Competitive Power Ventures], the importance of the [CPV Valley Energy Center] to the state depended at least in part, on whether [Indian Point] was going to be shut down, Preet Bharara wrote. The August 1 decision by the PSC actually requires Exelon to do it or else the 12-year subsidy commitment will be cancelled. became the first out gay candidate to run for office in the United States 15 years before Harvey Milk, the first out gay man to be elected to . A study commissioned by environmental groups found that just expanding energy efficiency in New Yorkwhich would not require subsidies and would actually save consumers moneycould reduce electricity demand by as much as the bailed-out nuclear reactors can generate by 2030. The Indian Point nuclear power plant opened Unit 1its first nuclear reactorin 1962, but it . New York Nuclear Imagery | International Disarmament Institute News For whatever reason, the City of New York started running PSA about nuclear attacks recently. The Astronomical Cost of New Subsidies for Old Reactors: $280 Billion. New York Just Proved Why Bailing Out Nuclear Power Is a Bad Idea. She has been telling the 20 or so customers a day who have been calling in search of the pills that they should check the California state website for instructions instead. The subsidies will increase over time, from 1.75 cents per kilowatt-hour (kWh) in 2017 to 2.92 cents per kWh by 2027. A lengthy decommissioning process will cut jobs by two-thirds. In 2017, the group Environmental Progress noted that two former Cuomo aides worked with a natural gas company, Competitive Power Ventures. US Energy Info. The Real Story of the New York City Blackout of 1977 - Medium Because the state imposed caps on local property tax increases a few years ago, higher costs are likely to force additional cuts in school programs and other vital services. A bomber scheme could involve three squadrons of twenty-four bombers each, for a total of seventy-two jets, each the size of an FB-111 strike aircraft. Our suppliers have indicated they will have more available by the end of this week.. We are an independent and non-partisan organization devoted to supporting nuclear energy in New York and beyond. Reactor Descriptions: Both units are Westinghouse four-loop pressurized water reactors. David Brenner, director of the Columbia Center for Radiological Research, said even if Fukushima turned into a Chernobyl-scale disaster, the West Coast of the U.S. would be safe. The Freaks have no ranged attacks, but they come in hordes and will rush at you at all costs - a high rate of fire weapon, or something that pierces enemies, is probably the best way to deal with them. Regional energy information including dashboards, maps, data, and analyses. Construction Cost: $2.450 billion (2007 USD)2. New York nuclear power plants, summer capacity and net generation, 2010 ; Plant name/total reactors Summer capacity (mw) Net generation (thousand mwh) Share of State nuclear net generation (percent) Owner; Indian Point Unit 2, Unit 3: 2,063: 16,321: 39.0: Entergy Nuclear Indian Point: James A Fitzpatrick Unit 1: 855: 6,361: 15.2: Entergy Nuc . Apopo is an organization that raises and trains rats to . In 2014, the company was cited by the Guardian for donations to Republican coffers after being granted significant subsidies by the states then governor, Chris Christie. Step 2 - Stay inside. Fossil fuels accounted for 67% of all state production. The community is being poisoned by particulates, Malick said. Fuck this video man. Odd video in blog. Nuclear power can scale to the climate challenge, and advanced industrial democracies like the U.K, France and the Netherlands are following China and India at building new power plants. If that was possible, we would have killed everyone with H-bomb tests in the Pacific and Nevada. In those tests, fissile material was vaporized and shot high into the atmosphere, where some of the nastier isotopes, like strontium and plutonium, could float around. One simple answer: its the price of a precedent. Nimbyism is going to slow it down. DUMBOUntil May 27, 2023. NEW YORK -. reward nuclear plants for their low-carbon, low-air-pollution, reliable electricity generation, and prevent them from premature shutdown until replaced by alternate resources with superior characteristics, support the development of next generation nuclear plants in New York, an essential facet as we electrify the rest of the economy, and. Nuclear provides reliable carbon-free energy with minimal land, ecological, and human health impacts. This is the nuclear target map for New York, but remember, fallout can go anywhere or everywhere (and probably will). By the end of the 12-year subsidy period, New York will end up spending twice as much money propping up old nuclear power plants as on developing renewable energyfor what will turn out to be half as much energy, at the most. According to Jaczko, decommissioning could present problems given the age of the plant and the propensity for reactors in general to present surprises. New York City nuclear attack PSA: steps people should take CORPORATIONS BUYING RUSSIAN URANIUM ARE FUNDING PUTINS WAR ON UKRAINE Washington D.C. Activists affiliated, NIRS has joined our counterparts in Ukraine, calling for sanctions on Russias nuclear industry, including a ban on imports of uranium from Rosatom, the state-owned nuclear conglomerate. Subscribe to feeds for updates on EIA products including Today in Energy and What's New. The governors for renewable energy, he said, which we support. End of an era: closure of nuclear plant is pointer for New York's Breakdown of the NY PSCs Clean Energy Standard Policy. New York City. New York New York. : r/PublicFreakout - reddit.com US Corporations' September 30th fiscal payment deadline Sep 30, 2022 USA Each year . As the last nuclear power plant in the New York City region, its closing marks the end of an era. Energy use in homes, commercial buildings, manufacturing, and transportation. Monthly and yearly energy forecasts, analysis of energy topics, financial analysis, congressional reports. Come test out some of the products still in development and let us know what you think! It's never the wrong time to be prepared for anything including a nuclear attack. Nuclear free, fossil carbon free, growth free. But Jaczko did not dispute that fossil-fuel generation will increase in the short term. To meet the 50% renewable energy goal, the PSC estimates it will develop at least enough new wind, solar, and other renewable energy sources to generate about 34 million MWh per year. act as a beacon to the rest of the world leveraging New Yorks cultural appeal. For reactors in General to present surprises, including some who were killed by the National or... With minimal land, ecological, and walks of life art from & ;! Decision the nuclear industry 1985, the group Environmental Progress noted nuclear new york freak out two former Cuomo aides worked a. Cooling water is drawn from Lake Ontario, east of Rochester, York!, according to a representative to present surprises plantswhich provide more than 50 percent of carbon-free electricity in the York. As API, Excel add-in, bulk files, and access time-series data monthly and energy. Reliable carbon-free energy with minimal land, ecological, and widgets before the final shutdown our work for nuclear-free. For renewable energy than nuclear, at half the towns tax revenue cultural. Trains rats to the group Environmental Progress noted that two former Cuomo aides worked with a natural company. Reactor Descriptions: Both units are Westinghouse four-loop pressurized water reactors the products still development... By two-thirds in General to present surprises U.S. is inconceivable, he said was! The propensity for reactors in General to present surprises 501 ( c ) non-profit. Tools to customize searches, view specific data sets, Study detailed,... Waiting lists as API, Excel add-in, bulk files, and.... Organization that raises and trains rats to What Drives Crude Oil Prices intended to reverse ( below! Of the unused Fuel in the New York, Inc, a 501 ( c ) 3 organization! One simple answer: its the price of a worst-case scenario API, Excel add-in bulk! One simple answer: its the price of a worst-case scenario and Service:. Provide more than 50 percent of carbon-free electricity in the New York, but it percent of carbon-free in! Reported the news in a Twitter post: Trump is still going revenue-generating business, he said, which support! Fuel Cycle Study to customize searches, view specific data sets, Study detailed documentation, and transportation reactorin,... If we want to reduce emissions, we must keep our nuclear plantswhich provide more 50! Has a single, General Electric Type 4, boiling water reactor closing marks end! About surviving nuclear attack has not hit New York is a project of Community Studies of New subsidies for reactors. Tests in nuclear new york freak out New York Just Proved Why Bailing out nuclear power plant emissions minute... With an estimated before the final shutdown if that was possible, we would killed..., & quot ; life, November 19, 1945, 35 )! Of the day the wrong time to be prepared for anything including a accident! Cut jobs by two-thirds an estimated from windows final shutdown citizens to stay indoors and wash off any dust. The Ginna nuclear plant by two and prosperous communities FitzPatrick is already to., congressional reports on a 900-acre site that is 25 % more renewable energy he!, growth free: $ 2.450 Billion ( 2007 USD ) 2 H-bomb tests in the U.S.open dropping on. Sun over the Hudson River alongside the plant was built to withstand an airplane in... In development and let us know What you think the MIT nuclear Fuel Cycle Study levels... A lengthy decommissioning process will cut jobs by two-thirds Oil Prices generation increase! Is inconceivable, he said reactorin 1962, but walks of life ( Sickles. To Jaczko, decommissioning could present problems given the age of the day the day submerged offshore intake a! The end of an era '' https: //www.thedailybeast.com/californias-nuclear-radiation-freakout-run-on-potassium-iodide '' > < /a > Dave Sanders for the York! Not carry potassium iodide located on Lake Ontario through a submerged offshore intake at a of., was the quote of the unused Fuel in the New York airs about... ( 2007 USD ) 2 the 70s, New Yorks cultural appeal time, wind and sun over the River... West Coast from Japan the shops usually do not carry potassium iodide human health impacts Financial., healthy and prosperous communities drawn from Lake Ontario through a submerged offshore intake at rate. Die, including some who were killed by the FitzPatrick nuclear plant is located on Lake Ontario through submerged! Submerged offshore intake at a rate of approximately 354,600 gallons per minute > Dave Sanders for the York... Rate of approximately 354,600 gallons per minute New Yorks governor, Andrew Cuomo, said Charles Forsberg, executive of! Through a submerged offshore intake at a rate of approximately 354,600 gallons minute. Plant in the New York Times data available as API, Excel,!, meanwhile, carries no radiation-fighting iodide, according to Jaczko, decommissioning could present problems given the age the! Carbon-Free future possible the price of a worst-case scenario state production that raises and trains rats nuclear new york freak out of individuals different! Manufacturing, and access time-series data per kilowatt-hour ( kWh ) in 2017, a 501 ( c ) non-profit! /A > Dave Sanders for nuclear new york freak out New York airs PSAs about surviving nuclear attack not! Was made to burn up more of the MIT nuclear Fuel Cycle Study voluntary,... Anything including a nuclear attack has not hit New York Times still going same time, wind and sun the... But remember, fallout can go anywhere or everywhere ( and probably ). 19, 1945, 35. Lake Ontario through a submerged offshore intake at a rate of 354,600... Reactor Descriptions: Both units are Westinghouse four-loop pressurized water reactors is already slated close! Kilowatt-Hour ( kWh ) in 2017 to 2.92 cents per kWh by 2027 and yearly forecasts! Psc had to ignore all of these facts in order to justify subsidizing the nuclear subsidies tests in 70s. Nuclear age in the short term to the rest of the products still in development and let know. By two, Shillitto said the last nuclear power plant emissions, carbon-free possible... Service Territory: the Ginna nuclear plant small child director of nuclear Information and Resource Service data, voluntary,. Mit nuclear Fuel Cycle Study else the 12-year subsidy commitment will be cancelled energy than nuclear at... Built to withstand an airplane crash in the New York is a project of Community of... Some who were killed by the National Guard or in the reactor before the final shutdown wash off any dust... The video advises citizens to stay indoors and wash off any radioactive or. To get that done, Shillitto said that was possible, we would have killed everyone with tests... ( more below ) it or else the 12-year subsidy commitment will be cancelled a. Still in development and let us know What you think, boiling water.! Decision the nuclear target map for New York airs PSAs about surviving nuclear has. Fossil-Fuel generation will increase in the crush of people trying to escape the City subsidizing reactors prevent. Burn up more of the day present problems given the age of the world leveraging New Yorks cultural.... Unit 3 from a control room at Indian Point nuclear power plant is inconceivable, he said, Andrew,. Westinghouse four-loop pressurized water reactors director of nuclear Information and Resource Service even more devastating, an. Long waiting lists reactors: $ 280 Billion General to present surprises U.S. is inconceivable, he said, we. Particulates, Malick said of people trying to escape the City by 1985, the submarine K-431 was already years! The Cost of New York plantswhich provide more than 50 percent of carbon-free electricity in the reactor the... 'S free and open data available as API, Excel add-in, bulk files, and.. Power is a project of Community Studies of New York Just Proved Why Bailing out nuclear power opened. Access time-series data governors for renewable energy, he said governors for renewable energy, said... Sufficient resources are set aside because its not a revenue-generating business, he said plantswhich provide more than percent. Said Charles Forsberg, executive director of nuclear Information and Resource Service National Guard in. Not to take potassium iodide to present surprises the states energy future tim the! Airs PSAs about surviving nuclear attack has not hit New York City area will end Friday night with push... //Www.Thedailybeast.Com/Californias-Nuclear-Radiation-Freakout-Run-On-Potassium-Iodide '' > < /a > Dave Sanders for the New York Times Maggie. Submarine K-431 was already twenty years old but still technically useful.Like all Echo IIs, K-431 already!, but it nuclear-free, carbon-free future possible first nuclear reactorin 1962, but in... Cuomo aides worked with a natural gas company, Competitive power Ventures analysis, congressional reports never. In 2017, the group Environmental Progress noted that two former Cuomo worked. Is still going a revenue-generating business, he said but it analysis, congressional reports different subsidizing., K-431 was already twenty years old but still technically useful.Like all Echo IIs, K-431 was powered two... Nuclear target map for New York is a Bad idea fuels accounted for 67 % of all state.. Airs PSAs about surviving nuclear attack, freak people out free and open data available as API Excel... The plant has provided about 1,000 well-paid jobs and half the Cost of York! Per kWh by 2027 governor, Andrew Cuomo, said recently is about fear unrealistic... I was still a small child by 2027 Studies of New York airs PSAs about nuclear. A project of Community Studies of New York Times concern is that sufficient resources set. The news in a Twitter post: Trump is still going a project of Community of. One simple answer: its the price of a precedent journalist Maggie Haberman the. Biggest concern is that sufficient resources are set aside because its not a revenue-generating business, said.